Jurisdiction: COMPARATIVE: FLORIDA vs CALIFORNIA
3-minute read
Bottom line: On October 21, 2026, Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal reversed a Miami-Dade trial judge who denied partition and ordered a reverse mortgage instead.[1] The court held that partition is a matter of right for co-owners of indivisible property and sent the case back with instructions to order a partition by sale.[1] For a sale, the court controls the path to closing, followed by an accounting.[1]
The trial judge’s fix sounded tidy: one owner takes out a reverse mortgage, pays the other two, and keeps an enhanced life estate in the home.[1] Nobody had asked for it in a pleading, and the appeals court threw it out.[1] If you work with co-owners, this Florida partition by sale ruling shows where a court’s discretion ends and the statute takes over.[1][2]
Real estate education, not legal advice.
How did a trial court try to avoid a property sale?
Three parties each owned an undivided one-third interest in an indivisible single-family home, as joint tenants with rights of survivorship under a 2013 deed.[1] After a non-jury trial, the trial court denied partition.[1]
Instead, it ordered the appellee to obtain a reverse mortgage for the maximum available amount, pay the net proceeds equally to both appellants, and deed herself an enhanced life estate with remainder to the appellants.[1] The order contained no findings of manifest injustice, fraud or oppression.[1] The appeals court said the remedy “was never requested in any pleading,” and courts are not authorized to award relief that was not requested.[1]
A court can’t swap a sale for a remedy no one pleaded.[1]
Does this apply everywhere, or just in Florida?
The Probate Lab works with agents and investors in all 50 states. California starts in a similar place.
- Florida: Citing § 64.051, the court said partition is a matter of right for co-owners of indivisible property.[1][2] A court may refuse it only in extreme cases or where manifest injustice, fraud or oppression will result.[1]
- California: Partition of concurrent interests “shall be as of right unless barred by a valid waiver,” except as provided in Section 872.730.[3]
In both states, the starting point is the co-owner’s right to partition, not the court’s idea of fairness.[1][3]
What does a Florida partition by sale order actually look like?
The parties agreed that each owns one-third and that the home cannot be divided in kind without prejudice.[1] The court called those “the only prerequisites for partition by sale” and remanded with instructions to order partition by sale, after which the trial court may conduct an accounting.[1] The opinion notes it is not final until any timely rehearing motion is resolved.[1]
Under § 64.071, when land cannot be divided without prejudice, the court may order it sold at public auction to the highest bidder by the commissioners or the clerk.[4] Unless the clerk sells it under s. 45.031, the sale is reported to the court, approved, and a conveyance ordered before any conveyance is made.[4] In California, the court shall order a sale when the parties agree or when sale and division of the proceeds would be more equitable than dividing the property, and it may appoint a referee.[5]
In Florida, a court-ordered sale needs the court’s approval before anyone conveys title.[4]
What do agents and investors tend to miss?
Don’t stop at the sale price. The trial court’s order “failed to take into account appreciation of the property and proportionate expenses.”[1] In a partition proceeding, there must be an accounting of whether each co-tenant paid a proportionate share of the expenses.[1]
Florida’s § 64.081 makes every party pay a share of costs, including attorneys’ fees, in proportion to that party’s interest.[6] In a sale, the court may order those costs and fees paid from the sale money, and all taxes due at the time of sale come out of the purchase money.[6]
The net to each owner depends on the accounting, the fees and the taxes, not just the sale price.[1][6]
Which three questions should you ask first?
- Do all owners agree on their shares, and can the property be divided in kind without prejudice?[1]
- Has anyone paid more than a proportionate share of the expenses, since the court may conduct an accounting?[1]
- Is there any claim of manifest injustice, fraud or oppression that could support refusing partition?[1]
Ask these early, before anyone promises an owner a number or a date.
Where to go from here
When a judge’s order changes the deal, do you know where to get the answer? If you don’t know where to get the answer, EPCAS™ is for you. The Elite Partition System course opens enrollment in Q4 2026.
EPCAS™ (Elite Probate Client Acquisition System) — $297
Sources
- Norma Dominguez, et al. v. Nancy Suarez, No. 3D25-0823 (Lower Tribunal No. 20-23756-CA-01, Miami-Dade County), Florida Third District Court of Appeal, opinion on motion for rehearing and clarification filed October 21, 2026 (quoting Condrey v. Condrey, 92 So. 2d 423, 427 (Fla. 1957)). https://flcourts-media.flcourts.gov/content/download/2497069/opinion/Opinion_2025-0823.pdf
- Florida Statutes § 64.051 (Judgment). https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0000-0099/0064/Sections/0064.051.html
- California Code of Civil Procedure § 872.710(b). https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CCP§ionNum=872.710
- Florida Statutes § 64.071(1), (3) (Sale where nondivisible). https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0000-0099/0064/Sections/0064.071.html
- California Code of Civil Procedure § 872.820. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CCP§ionNum=872.820
- Florida Statutes § 64.081 (Costs; taxes; attorneys’ fees). https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0000-0099/0064/Sections/0064.081.html
Every source above was checked against the original on October 27, 2026.
Quick answers
Three parties each owned an undivided one-third interest in an indivisible single-family home, as joint tenants with rights of survivorship under a 2013 deed. After a non-jury trial, the trial court denied partition.
The Probate Lab works with agents and investors in all 50 states. California starts in a similar place.
The parties agreed that each owns one-third and that the home cannot be divided in kind without prejudice. The court called those “the only prerequisites for partition by sale” and remanded with instructions to order partition by sale, after which the trial court may conduct an accounting. The opinion notes it is not final until any timely rehearing motion is resolved.
Don’t stop at the sale price. The trial court’s order “failed to take into account appreciation of the property and proportionate expenses.” In a partition proceeding, there must be an accounting of whether each co-tenant paid a proportionate share of the expenses.
Ask these early, before anyone promises an owner a number or a date.


Leave a Reply