Jurisdiction: COMPARATIVE: CALIFORNIA vs. MINNESOTA (federal Medicaid baseline)
3-minute read
Bottom line: On October 9, 2026, a published California Court of Appeal decision barred the Department of Health Care Services from recovering “excess capitation” from Medi-Cal members’ estates and voided the regulation behind it.[1] The claim is limited to “an amount equal to the payments for the health care services received.”[1] When the house is the estate’s main asset, that number shapes what heirs net from the sale.
A Medi-Cal managed care plan received $261,957.40 for one woman’s coverage and paid her providers $106,672.71, yet the state sought the larger figure, plus premiums and interest, from what she left behind.[1] That gap is the center of a new Medi-Cal estate recovery ruling, and it sits on the money a probate sale produces.
This is real estate education, not legal advice. Rules vary by state.
What did the court say the state cannot bill an estate for?
In managed care, Medi-Cal pays the plan a fixed monthly amount for each member, whether or not the member receives care.[1] The Department claimed that capitation from estates even when it exceeded what the plan spent.[1] For Theodosia Phillip, a nursing facility resident from 2010 until her death in 2015, it sought $407,774.41, including $139,964.71 in interest.[1]
Reading Welfare and Institutions Code section 14009.5, the court held excess capitation is not recoverable.[1] It declared void the regulation that counted “payments to managed care plans,” California Code of Regulations, title 22, section 50961, subdivision (c).[1] It affirmed a writ requiring the Department to stop collecting excess capitation and reprocess certain class claims.[1]
The claim is measured by the care paid for, not by what the plan was paid.
Is this the rule in every state, or only in California?
Federal Medicaid law requires states to seek recovery from the estate of a person who got the care at 55 or older for nursing facility services, home and community-based services, and related hospital and prescription drug services.[2] It lets each state decide whether “estate” reaches past probate to joint tenancy, a living trust or a similar arrangement.[2] For deaths on or after January 1, 2017, California limits repayment to estate assets subject to probate.[3]
Minnesota’s Supreme Court held in May 2025 that the state may recover the capitation it paid for a recipient’s long-term care services after age 55, $66,052.62 in that case.[4] The California court distinguished it: Minnesota sought only that actuarially limited portion, not the full capitation.[1] The Probate Lab works with agents and investors in all 50 states.
Which assets the claim can reach, and how it is priced, depend on the state.
Why does a Medi-Cal estate recovery claim matter at the closing table?
In California, whoever handles a deceased Medi-Cal member’s affairs must send the Department a notice of death within 90 days, with a copy of the death certificate.[3] If the house is the only real asset, any claim comes out of its sale proceeds.
In Phillip, the estate conceded $106,901.12 of a $407,774.41 claim.[1] A gap like that does not move the sale price. It moves the net, which is what heirs fight over when one wants to sell and another wants to keep the house.
The market sets the price; the claim helps set what the family keeps.
What gets missed when Medi-Cal paid for the last years?
As of 2025, more than 10 million Medi-Cal members, about 95 percent, received care through capitated managed care.[1] The Department may waive a claim for substantial hardship, but the request is due within 60 days of the date on its claim letter.[3]
The decision is published.[1] A civil appeal decision is final in the Court of Appeal 30 days after filing, and a petition for review is due 10 days later, so the Department could still ask the California Supreme Court to take it up.[5][6]
Ask about the claim early, and confirm the ruling is final before relying on it.
Which three questions come before you talk about the net?
- Did the decedent receive Medi-Cal benefits on or after age 55, and through a managed care plan?[1][3]
- Has the Department sent a claim letter, and does its figure count capitation or care received?[1]
- Is the house a probate asset, and when does the 60-day hardship window close?[3]
Those answers belong with the attorney before you promise anyone a number.
Where does EPCAS™ fit in?
Money comes up early with a probate family, and an estate recovery claim can change the answer. When an heir asks what they will walk away with, do you know where to get the answer? If you don’t know where to get the answer, EPCAS™ (Elite Probate Client Acquisition System) is for you.
EPCAS™ (Elite Probate Client Acquisition System) — $297
Sources
- Phillip v. Baass, Court of Appeal of California, Second Appellate District, Division Six, No. B341853 (San Luis Obispo County Super. Ct. No. 17CV-0261), filed October 9, 2026, certified for publication. https://www4.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/B341853.PDF
- Social Security Act § 1917(b)(1)(B) and (b)(4) (42 U.S.C. § 1396p(b)(1)(B), (b)(4)), Social Security Administration. https://ssa.gov/OP_Home/ssact/title19/1917.htm
- California Department of Health Care Services, Estate Recovery Program. https://www.dhcs.ca.gov/services/estate-recovery-program/
- In re Estate of Ecklund, Supreme Court of Minnesota, No. A23-0210, filed May 7, 2025 (20 N.W.3d 351). https://mncourts.gov/mncourtsgov/media/Appellate/Supreme%20Court/Standard%20Opinions/OPA230210-050725.pdf
- California Rules of Court, rule 8.264(b)(1), finality of a Court of Appeal decision. https://courts.ca.gov/cms/rules/index/eight/rule8_264
- California Rules of Court, rule 8.500(e)(1), time to file a petition for review. https://www.courts.ca.gov/cms/rules/index/eight/rule8_500
Statutory and opinion text is quoted so it can be verified. Application of any of it to a specific estate is a legal question for the attorney on the file.
Every source above was checked against the original on November 10, 2026.
Quick answers
In managed care, Medi-Cal pays the plan a fixed monthly amount for each member, whether or not the member receives care. The Department claimed that capitation from estates even when it exceeded what the plan spent. For Theodosia Phillip, a nursing facility resident from 2010 until her death in 2015, it sought $407,774.41, including $139,964.71 in interest.
Federal Medicaid law requires states to seek recovery from the estate of a person who got the care at 55 or older for nursing facility services, home and community-based services, and related hospital and prescription drug services. It lets each state decide whether “estate” reaches past probate to joint tenancy, a living trust or a similar arrangement.
In California, whoever handles a deceased Medi-Cal member’s affairs must send the Department a notice of death within 90 days, with a copy of the death certificate. If the house is the only real asset, any claim comes out of its sale proceeds.
As of 2025, more than 10 million Medi-Cal members, about 95 percent, received care through capitated managed care. The Department may waive a claim for substantial hardship, but the request is due within 60 days of the date on its claim letter.
Those answers belong with the attorney before you promise anyone a number.
Money comes up early with a probate family, and an estate recovery claim can change the answer. When an heir asks what they will walk away with, do you know where to get the answer? If you don’t know where to get the answer, EPCAS™ (Elite Probate Client Acquisition System) is for you.


Leave a Reply