Does a Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Lien Survive a Receiver’s Sale?

Navy and gold PACE lien card with the headline “Does a Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Lien Survive a Receiver’s Sale?” above the line CALIFORNIA · Court of Appeal, Fourth District and the source Diplomat Property Manager v. FortiFi Financial, No. D086371 (2026).

Written by

in

·

Jurisdiction: CALIFORNIA · Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division One

3-minute read

Bottom line: In Diplomat Property Manager v. FortiFi Financial, filed September 23, 2026 and certified for publication October 20, 2026, a California Court of Appeal affirmed the denial of an anti-Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation (anti-SLAPP) motion.[1] The procedural ruling is narrow. The facts it describes, a receivership sale and a PACE lien (an assessment lien) that did not go away, are what matter at a closing table.[1]

A construction lender says it watched eight defaulted properties go through a court receivership and saw a Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) lien paid ahead of it out of the sale proceeds.[1] It is now suing to recover $844,205, the amount it expects to be paid to that lien through escrow.[1] If you buy, list or lend on court-ordered sales, would your file have priced that assessment before the deal was set?

This is real estate education, not legal advice. Rules vary by state, so confirm the details with your broker and the attorney on the file.

What is a PACE assessment, and why does it sit first?

California’s PACE program lets owners finance renewable energy and efficiency upgrades and have the cost added to their property tax bill, paid in installments.[1] Recording the notice of assessment is what makes it a lien.[1] In the court’s words: “By law, the PACE liens take priority over other liens and run with the property.”[1]

It is collected like a tax and ranks ahead of the deed of trust, so it does not behave like a mortgage.

What happened at the receiver’s sales?

After the developer’s company, Top Flight, defaulted on its construction loans and let the property taxes go delinquent, the trial court “appointed a receiver over specific Top Flight properties and later expanded the receiver’s powers so the receiver could market and sell all eight of the defaulted Top Flight properties.”[1] The receiver sought an order that the assessment administrator, FortiFi, understood would let two homes sell clear of all liens without paying the assessments, and FortiFi intervened to oppose it.[1]

The court then “issued orders directing the receiver to pay delinquent PACE assessments and confirming the PACE liens would continue to run with the property after the sale unless prepaid in full.”[1] According to the lender, Diplomat Property Manager, most buyers would not take the properties subject to the liens, so the receiver paid them off first from proceeds otherwise headed to Diplomat.[1]

Paying what was past due did not retire the lien. Payoff in full did.

Why couldn’t the court simply strip the PACE lien?

FortiFi argued in the receivership case that article XIII, section 32 of the California Constitution and Revenue and Taxation Code section 4807 bar any court order that would prevent or enjoin the collection of property taxes, which include these assessments, and FortiFi says the court agreed.[1] The Court of Appeal found no indication the trial court intended to strip the liens, which left two options: pay them off in full to give buyers clean title, or sell subject to them.[1]

The appellate holding itself is procedural. Recording the assessments was not protected prelitigation activity under Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16, and the lender’s claims did not arise from FortiFi’s conduct in the receivership litigation, so the order denying the motion to strike was affirmed.[1]

On a court-ordered sale, some debts are paid out of escrow and some ride with the deed.

Would your file have caught it?

This was a receivership. Would the same question come up on a partition, probate or trust sale with a contractual assessment on the tax bill? Before pricing, a few things to ask:

  1. Does the tax bill carry a contractual assessment as a separate line from the base tax?
  2. Is the figure on the payoff demand the delinquent amount or the full balance?
  3. Will the buyer take title subject to the assessment, or does the sale order require payoff in full?

This decision describes California’s program. How another state’s assessment programs rank and collect is a question for local counsel and the title company.

Price the encumbrance that survives the deed, not only the ones on the payoff list.

Where to go from here

When a court-ordered sale carries an assessment that won’t come off at closing, do you know where to get the answer? If you don’t know where to get the answer, EPCAS™ (Elite Probate Client Acquisition System) is for you.

EPCAS™ (Elite Probate Client Acquisition System) — $297

Sources

  1. Diplomat Property Manager v. FortiFi Financial, No. D086371 (San Diego County Superior Court No. 24CU007912C), California Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division One, filed September 23, 2026; certified for publication October 20, 2026 (order attached to the opinion). https://www4.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/D086371.PDF

Statutory and opinion text is quoted so it can be verified. Application of any of it to a specific file is a legal question and routes to attorney sign-off.

Every source above was checked against the original on November 1, 2026.

Quick answers

What is a PACE assessment, and why does it sit first?

California’s PACE program lets owners finance renewable energy and efficiency upgrades and have the cost added to their property tax bill, paid in installments. Recording the notice of assessment is what makes it a lien. In the court’s words: “By law, the PACE liens take priority over other liens and run with the property.”

What happened at the receiver’s sales?

After the developer’s company, Top Flight, defaulted on its construction loans and let the property taxes go delinquent, the trial court “appointed a receiver over specific Top Flight properties and later expanded the receiver’s powers so the receiver could market and sell all eight of the defaulted Top Flight properties.”

Why couldn’t the court simply strip the PACE lien?

FortiFi argued in the receivership case that article XIII, section 32 of the California Constitution and Revenue and Taxation Code section 4807 bar any court order that would prevent or enjoin the collection of property taxes, which include these assessments, and FortiFi says the court agreed.

Would your file have caught it?

This was a receivership. Would the same question come up on a partition, probate or trust sale with a contractual assessment on the tax bill? Before pricing, a few things to ask:

Deric Rangell Avatar

About the author

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *