Did the Owner Die Before Closing With a Transfer on Death Deed Pending Sale?

The Probate Lab ruling card: Did the owner die before closing with a transfer on death deed pending sale? Ohio vs Missouri.

Written by

in

·

Jurisdiction: COMPARATIVE: OHIO vs MISSOURI

3-minute read

Bottom line: On October 5, 2026, an Ohio appeals court held that a binding sale contract signed before death turns the owner’s land into a right to the sale money.[1] Even with an unrevoked transfer-on-death affidavit on record, the proceeds went to the estate under the will.[1] A 2023 Missouri appeals decision on similar facts went the other way.[4]

Two sets of family members are looking at the same $350,000 sale, and each side points to a different document.[1] In December 2021, an Ohio landowner signed a $350,000 contract for nearly 62 acres in Orwell, Ohio; it became effective on December 27 when the buyer signed.[1] She died the next day, with a 2010 transfer on death designation affidavit still on record and a July 2021 will leaving everything to two people.[1] How your state handles a transfer on death deed pending sale tells you whether the executor or the named beneficiaries close the deal.

Real estate education, not legal advice.

What happens to a transfer on death deed pending sale in Ohio?

In Estate of Hovanick, Ohio’s Eleventh Appellate District called this a question of first impression in Ohio’s appellate districts.[1] Ohio’s affidavit must be recorded before death to be effective,[2] and it can be revoked or changed only by recording a new affidavit before death,[1][3] which this owner never did.[1]

The court still held that an owner’s “written, unconditional, and specifically enforceable contract to sell real property, entered into before her death, effects an equitable conversion of the owner’s interest in that property into a right to the proceeds of sale.”[1] Under Ohio’s statute, the beneficiary “has no interest in the real property until the death of the owner”[3] and “takes only the interest that the deceased owner or owners of the interest held on the date of death.”[3]

In Ohio’s Eleventh District, conversion happens “as of the date of signing, not the date of closing.”[1]

Why do Ohio and Missouri split on the same timeline?

The Probate Lab works with agents and investors in all 50 states. Here, the state line matters.

  • Ohio (Eleventh Appellate District): A binding contract signed before death sends the proceeds to the estate; a mere preliminary agreement does not.[1]
  • Missouri (Southern District): The owner signed a beneficiary deed in 2012, his attorney-in-fact signed a sale contract in June 2021, and he died in October 2021 before any deed was delivered. The property passed to the beneficiary.[4]

Missouri law says a “transfer during the owner’s lifetime of the owner’s interest in property, with or without consideration, terminates the beneficiary designation with respect to the property transferred.”[5] The Ohio court distinguished the Missouri case because Missouri requires deed delivery to transfer ownership, while Ohio’s only revocation method is recording a new affidavit.[1]

Similar facts, two states, two different people holding the money.[1][4]

Who gets the check, and who signs at closing?

In Ohio, if no contract was signed before death, the affidavit controls.[1] If a binding contract exists, the proceeds pass under the will, not to the affidavit beneficiaries.[1]

The deal stays alive for the buyer. The beneficiaries hold bare legal title in trust for the buyer, the estate must convey legal title, and the buyer owes the purchase price to the estate.[1] In the Missouri case, the property was not estate property, and the personal representative could not get specific performance of the contract through probate.[4]

Equitable conversion decides whether the buyer pays the estate or the property goes to the beneficiary.[1][4]

What is easy to miss in the county records?

It is easy to pull the records, see an unrevoked transfer-on-death instrument, and assume the named beneficiaries control the property and the payoff. In Ohio, a binding pre-death contract still moved the $350,000 in proceeds to the estate.[1]

The document that decides who gets paid may be the signed purchase agreement, not the recorded instrument.[1]

What three questions should you ask when a seller dies before closing?

  1. Was the agreement a written, unconditional, and specifically enforceable contract signed before death?[1]
  2. Was the transfer-on-death instrument recorded before death,[2] and did the owner record a new affidavit or deliver a deed during life?[3][4]
  3. Does your state treat a pre-death contract as an equitable conversion, as Ohio’s Eleventh District did,[1] or end a beneficiary designation only on a lifetime transfer, as in Missouri?[4][5]

Ask these before you promise anyone a closing date.

Where to go from here

Spotting where title, probate and a pending contract collide earns trust with attorneys, executors and heirs. When this question lands on your desk, do you know where to get the answer? If you don’t know where to get the answer, EPCAS™ is for you.

EPCAS™ (Elite Probate Client Acquisition System) — $297

Sources

  1. Estate of Hovanick, 2026-Ohio-3915, Ohio Court of Appeals, Eleventh Appellate District (Ashtabula County), Case No. 2026-A-0014, decided October 5, 2026. https://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/11/2026/2026-Ohio-3915.pdf
  2. Ohio Revised Code § 5302.22(F). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5302.22
  3. Ohio Revised Code § 5302.23(B)(4), (B)(5), (B)(7)(a). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-5302.23
  4. In the Estate of Anthony M. Vrana; Sandra Fidura-Phillips v. Aaron Wilson, No. SD37889, Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District, filed September 25, 2023, 676 S.W.3d 344. https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=201453
  5. Missouri Revised Statutes § 461.033.5. https://revisor.mo.gov/main/OneSection.aspx?section=461.033

Every source above was checked against the original on October 20, 2026.

Quick answers

What happens to a transfer on death deed pending sale in Ohio?

In Estate of Hovanick, Ohio’s Eleventh Appellate District called this a question of first impression in Ohio’s appellate districts. Ohio’s affidavit must be recorded before death to be effective, and it can be revoked or changed only by recording a new affidavit before death, which this owner never did.

Why do Ohio and Missouri split on the same timeline?

The Probate Lab works with agents and investors in all 50 states. Here, the state line matters.

Who gets the check, and who signs at closing?

In Ohio, if no contract was signed before death, the affidavit controls. If a binding contract exists, the proceeds pass under the will, not to the affidavit beneficiaries.

What is easy to miss in the county records?

It is easy to pull the records, see an unrevoked transfer-on-death instrument, and assume the named beneficiaries control the property and the payoff. In Ohio, a binding pre-death contract still moved the $350,000 in proceeds to the estate.

What three questions should you ask when a seller dies before closing?

Ask these before you promise anyone a closing date.

Deric Rangell Avatar

About the author

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *