Jurisdiction: CALIFORNIA · Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division Three
3-minute read
Bottom line: In McKinley v. Harris, filed October 13, 2026 and certified for publication, a California Court of Appeal affirmed an Orange County probate court’s refusal to award a trustee attorney fees she spent defending herself in her individual capacity.[1] The court said the probate court’s equitable powers protect “the trust estate,” “not the trustee’s personal assets.”[1]
Two San Clemente hotels held in a family trust were listed for sale when a beneficiary sued the trustees and recorded a notice of pending action, called a lis pendens, on each hotel.[1] By August 2024 the trustees told the court a buyer had offered $15.5 million, and that the petition and the notices had “obstructed our ability to get finalized contracts for the sale of the Properties.”[1] If you take trust listings, how often do you ask whether anyone has sued the trustee personally?
This is real estate education, not legal advice. Rules vary by state, so confirm the details with your broker and the attorney on the file.
How did one petition hold up a hotel sale?
Erin Harris and her spouse were trustees of a family trust whose three equal beneficiaries were Harris and her two siblings, and the trust held two hotels in San Clemente.[1] In March 2024, Harris told her sibling Andrew McKinley the trust had listed the hotels.[1] In May 2024 he filed a verified petition under Probate Code section 850, naming the trustees and naming Harris individually, and recorded two lis pendens.[1] He withdrew the lis pendens in mid-September 2024 and asked to dismiss the petition in October 2024; the court granted the dismissal in December 2024.[1] The opinion does not say whether the hotels sold.
By the trustees’ own account, the petition and the recorded notices held up the contracts.
Why did the trustee pay her own attorney fees after winning?
After the dismissal, the trustees, acting as trustees, asked for $656,929.02 in fees and costs. The probate court denied that motion but noted they might seek reimbursement from trust property by petition; that order is not at issue on the appeal.[1] Harris separately sought $83,434.50 in fees she incurred individually. The probate court awarded her costs but denied the fees.[1]
The Court of Appeal explained that a probate court’s equitable power includes charging fees against a beneficiary’s share when that beneficiary, in bad faith, brings an unfounded proceeding against the trust.[1] None of the cases Harris cited holds that power “can be used to award attorney fees to a trustee who incurred them solely for her personal defense or benefit.”[1] A modification order filed October 14, 2026 removed “, as Trustee, etc.” from the caption and “does not effect a change in the judgment.”[2]
Sued as trustee and sued personally are two different fee questions.
Why do trustee attorney fees matter on a trust listing?
California’s general rule, Code of Civil Procedure section 1021, applied here, is that each party bears its own attorney fees unless a statute or agreement provides otherwise.[1] A trustee named personally may carry her own defense bill. That is a financial reason to settle, discount or slow down, and none of those shows up as a stated reason on a listing that goes stale. A few intake questions:
- Is any petition pending under Probate Code section 850 or otherwise, and in what capacity is the trustee named?
- Is a lis pendens recorded against the property?
- Has the trustee’s attorney flagged anything that could change the timeline?
What a section 850 petition does to a pending sale, and what a trustee may or may not recover, are legal questions. The citation is here so counsel can read it; the application belongs to counsel.
Ask who has been sued, and in what capacity, before you promise anyone a closing date.
Where to go from here
When a trust sale stalls and nobody says why, do you know where to get the answer? If you don’t know where to get the answer, EPCAS™ (Elite Probate Client Acquisition System) is for you.
EPCAS™ (Elite Probate Client Acquisition System) — $297
Sources
- McKinley v. Harris, No. G066032 (Orange County Superior Court No. 30-2024-01398694), California Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division Three, filed October 13, 2026, certified for publication. https://www4.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/G066032.PDF
- McKinley v. Harris, No. G066032, order modifying opinion, no change in judgment, filed October 14, 2026. https://www4.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/G066032M.PDF
Statutory and opinion text is quoted so it can be verified. Application of any of it to a specific file is a legal question and routes to attorney sign-off.
Every source above was checked against the original on November 1, 2026.
Quick answers
Erin Harris and her spouse were trustees of a family trust whose three equal beneficiaries were Harris and her two siblings, and the trust held two hotels in San Clemente. In March 2024, Harris told her sibling Andrew McKinley the trust had listed the hotels. In May 2024 he filed a verified petition under Probate Code section 850, naming the trustees and naming Harris individually, and recorded two lis pendens.
After the dismissal, the trustees, acting as trustees, asked for $656,929.02 in fees and costs. The probate court denied that motion but noted they might seek reimbursement from trust property by petition; that order is not at issue on the appeal. Harris separately sought $83,434.50 in fees she incurred individually. The probate court awarded her costs but denied the fees.
California’s general rule, Code of Civil Procedure section 1021, applied here, is that each party bears its own attorney fees unless a statute or agreement provides otherwise. A trustee named personally may carry her own defense bill. That is a financial reason to settle, discount or slow down, and none of those shows up as a stated reason on a listing that goes stale. A few intake questions:


Leave a Reply